In this story · 3 sections
The argument about returning to the office has been conducted in anecdotes: the empty floor, the full coffee shop, the manager who counts badges. Lease data is less dramatic and more useful.
Across major cities, the demand for office space has not collapsed. It has sorted. Newer buildings with good light, efficient floors and credible transport links are holding up. Older buildings in weaker locations are not.
The flight to quality
Tenants who can choose are choosing less space, better space. A company that once took four floors may take two and a smaller meeting suite. The total square footage falls even as the quality of the space rises.
That is a problem for landlords of older stock, who cannot compete on amenities without spending capital they may not have. The result is a widening gap between assets, not a single market clearing price.
Hybrid work did not reduce the need for offices. It reduced the tolerance for bad ones.
Conversion is harder than it sounds
Converting offices to housing is the policy answer of choice, and it works in some buildings. It does not work in all. Floor plates may be too deep for residential light. Plumbing and fire safety require expensive changes. The maths depends on local prices and permits.
Where conversion does happen, it can add housing in places with jobs and transport — a genuine gain. Where it does not, the building may sit empty while the city waits for demand to return.
Context
What the data can and cannot show
Lease data records transactions, not use. A building can be fully leased and half occupied. Headline vacancy rates lag the experience of the tenants inside.
The second-order effects
Cities are already adapting. Some are relaxing rules on ground-floor use, allowing shops, studios and clinics into districts that were once purely corporate. Others are investing in public space to make the walk from station to desk more pleasant.
The office is not coming back in the form it left. It is becoming a service, chosen for specific purposes: collaboration, training, the occasional week together. The buildings that survive will be the ones that accept this, rather than waiting for the badge counts to return to 2019.
Join the conversation
0 commentsNo comments yet. Add a considered thought — comments are moderated by the editors.