In this story · 4 sections
Every newsroom I have worked in has had a version of the same conversation. The traffic is down. The answer is more: more stories, more posts, more alerts, more formats. The possibility that the answer is less is rarely tested.
I think it is time to test it.
The cost of abundance
When publishing was expensive, editors made choices. A story had to earn its place. Now the marginal cost of another article is close to zero, and the result is an internet that is technically full and practically empty.
The reader’s problem is not a shortage of information. It is a shortage of trust. More volume does not solve that. It makes it worse.
A publication is not a feed. It is a promise about what is worth your time.
What less looks like
Fewer stories, each with more reporting. A clear position on what the publication covers and what it does not. A front page that reflects editorial judgement rather than a content calendar.
This is not nostalgia for print. It is an argument about attention. If a story is not worth an editor’s time, it is unlikely to be worth a reader’s.
Context
The business objection
Less content means fewer page views, and page views are how advertising is sold. That is true. It is also why the model has to change: reader revenue, membership, events and clearly labelled advertising that does not require a flood of pages.
The AI problem
The arrival of cheap generated text makes the argument urgent. When anyone can produce a thousand plausible articles, the value of a publication is not its output. It is its judgement.
Judgement cannot be generated. It is the accumulated result of reporting, argument, correction and memory. A publication that publishes less, but stands behind more, is making a bet on that difference.
A test
For the next month, ask of every proposed story: would we be comfortable if this were the only thing a new reader saw from us?
If the answer is no, do not publish it. The internet will survive the silence. It might even benefit from it.
Join the conversation
0 commentsNo comments yet. Add a considered thought — comments are moderated by the editors.